Subscribe      List an Event or Business      Invite a Writer      Write for WN      Writers      Other Locations
list an event      1 million Australian readers every month      facebook

Where's the Best Lemon Tart in Melbourne?

Home > Melbourne > Food and Wine | Cafes | Shopping | Questions
Writer's Answer:
by Sue Williams (subscribe)
Writer, bushwalker, dessert enthusiast. Author of the Rusty Bore Mysteries. More info here: https://www.textpublishing.com.au/books/live-and-let-fry
Published September 13th 2011
Quite feasibly the perfect lemon tart
Quite feasibly the perfect lemon tart


Some claim the lemon tart is the Audrey Hepburn of desserts. Elegant and understated, the petite tarte au citron has a devoted following, who argue it is the greatest dessert of all time.

But where in Melbourne does the committed lemon enthusiast find the perfect lemon tart? And what constitutes the perfect lemon tart, anyhow?

For me, the filling must be custardy and smooth in texture, definitely not something akin to cheese cake. The flavour: a sublime mix of sweet with a lingering tang of lemon. And the pasty must be firm, short-crust in style, truly crisp and just a little bit buttery.

Another important factor is the price. Lemon tarts in Melbourne can be alarmingly expensive. Laurent's delectable specimen is a somewhat shocking $7.70 and frankly, this is just one tiny (albeit perfect, but still only tiny) tart. The French Lettuce sells a similarly wonderful (small) offering, icing-sugar-dusted, also with a frightening price tag.

The French Lettuce version
The French Lettuce version


My recommendation for the ideal combination of perfect tart and reasonable price is A Treat Of France Boulangerie and Patisserie at 765 Nicholson Road, Carlton North.

For $4.50, the lemon-sleuth is rewarded with a smooth, custardy lemon filling in a perfect pastry base. A cute unexpected addition is the little green "X" on top apparently to differentiate it from the passionfruit version. My only complaint with this establishment is that it's closed on Mondays.

So what's your view? If you're aware of a secret stash of tasty lemon tarts in Melbourne or even know how to whip up a first-class one yourself, please feel free to leave a comment below.
Help us improve  Click here if you liked this article  38
Share: email  facebook  twitter
Babka Bakery Cafe (358 Brunswick St, Fitzroy) serves up a rich lemon curd tart with burnt sugar topping for $7.50 :)
By debor - reader
Thursday, 15th of September @ 03:26 am
Without doubt, Browns Bakers of Distinction, who have ten stores located all over Melbourne. It's delicious, and an all-time favourite at every family function.
By meg.h - reader
Monday, 19th of September @ 01:35 am
Love me a good lemon tart. Thanks for the suggestions.
By Anna Bourozikas - senior reviewer
Wednesday, 14th of September @ 09:27 am
Mr Tulk at the state library has a surprisingly good one
By tian_ - reader
Thursday, 15th of September @ 12:43 am
For a very reasonable cost i can't go past Pelligra cakes pasticceria & gelateria 71 main street Greensborough... bit of a hike but extremely well worth it!
By roshi - reader
Monday, 19th of September @ 12:10 am
Liliana's gourmet 8/150 kellets rd, Rowville. U need to order in advance but they r the best! I can get them in gluten free too!
By tanb - reader
Tuesday, 20th of September @ 01:25 am
Ooh now I'm drooling over the babka variety, drats I was a few doors away today, must try it next time.
We were at barwon heads last week and they served up a delicious slice of lemon curd pie (huge with cream for $8) at the lovely pier side restaurant called "at the heads"

OT - but their pecan pie was great too
By Lesley Mitchell - senior reviewer
Monday, 20th of February @ 07:22 am
Beer Deluxe
Federation SQUARE
MELBOURNE
By Anonymous
Monday, 31st of October @ 10:44 am
If you feel like making one, I have been told that my lemon tart, based on Stephanie Alexander's recipe (but I use a biscuit base) is comparable to those listed below. Don't tell Stephanie, but I use lemon juice from a bottle when lemons are not in season, and I can make a family sized tart for probably not much more than the tini (but delish) Laurent's single serve.
By Joanne Tarasuik - senior reviewer
Monday, 28th of November @ 11:45 pm
Wow, jotar, I like the sound of your recipe. I hope you'll post it on Weekend Notes some day? It sounds delish :)
By Sue Williams - senior reviewer
Tuesday, 29th of November @ 12:57 am
Babka in Fitzroy serves the best lemon curd brulee tart, hands down. The worst: Brunetti's. Didn't go past the first spoonful.
By heyad - reader
Tuesday, 6th of December @ 04:36 am
I must try Babka - thanks for the tip. And thanks Lesley, next time I'm in Barwon Heads I definitely know where I'm headed....
By Sue Williams - senior reviewer
Monday, 20th of February @ 09:07 am
Le Petit gateau for sure!
www.lepetitgateau.com.au
By Anonymous
Wednesday, 25th of July @ 03:36 am
Shepherd's Bakehouse, Mt Eliza - Devine!
By jill_ - reader
Tuesday, 11th of June @ 10:38 pm

Articles from other cities
Featured
Top Events
Popular Articles
Categories
Lists
Questions