Subscribe      List an Event or Business      Invite a Writer      Write for WN      Writers      Other Locations
list an event      1 million Australian readers every month      facebook

Where is the Best Vanilla Slice in Melbourne?

Home > Melbourne > Shopping | Food and Wine | Cafes | Questions
Writer's Answer:
by Sue Williams (subscribe)
Writer, bushwalker, dessert enthusiast. Author of the Rusty Bore Mysteries. More info here:
Published August 20th 2011
The perfect vanilla slice moments before it...disappeared
The perfect vanilla slice moments disappeared

The search for the perfect vanilla slice is one that can last a lifetime. This custardy crusade is worthy of a tick box under "Religion" on the Census.

Some people perform good deeds, some spend years learning to meditate and others head to the Kingdom of Bhutan. But to those in pursuit of true happiness, I say get thee to the French Lettuce.

At this small, friendly establishment in Carlton, the weary pilgrim is greeted with a very large, very deep, smooth custardy-centre within wonderfully crisp pastry so fresh you can smell it.

The Age says it is the best vanilla slice.

The Herald Sun says it is the best vanilla slice.

And Michaelie Clark says it is the best vanilla slice.

These are mystics worth attending to.

Note, however, that the French Lettuce vanilla slice is not one to eat on a first date. Unless you have snake-like jaws that know how to unhinge, you will find this deep slice tricky to get into with dignity intact. Morsels of creamy custard may wobble onto your lap. A trail of deliciously crunchy crumbs of pastry may speckle your face. And some pilgrims may even make small, embarrassing snuffles and/or moans as they eat.

Regardless of your vanilla slice deportment, you can take comfort that this is a slice entrenched in culture. It's said (at least according to the gospels of Wikipedia) that the custardy forebear of the vanilla slice is none other than the mille-feuille, originating in France.

Mille feuille by Zantastik, Wikipedia
Mille feuille by Zantastik, Wikipedia

Vanilla slice pilgrims willing to venture further afield should also investigate Bayswater Cake Kitchen and Tatura Hot Bread, both multiple award winners in the annual Ouyen Vanilla Slice Competition.

If you have a preferred shrine to the vanilla slice in Melbourne or indeed anywhere in Victoria, please feel free to leave a comment below.
Help us improve  Click here if you liked this article  64
Share: email  facebook  twitter
Well, I've been called many things, but not yet a mystic until now! Vanilla slice hunting is indeed a journey - and I still stand by my assertion, The French Lettuce slice is far and away the most sublime example of custardy goodness I've had the pleasure to experience :)
By Michaelie Clark - senior reviewer
Sunday, 21st of August @ 07:49 am
I agree wholeheartedly with your assertion!
By Sue Williams - senior reviewer
Sunday, 21st of August @ 10:01 am
No doubt, the best Vanilla Slice in Melbourne is from Aviv Bakery in Elsternwick. Second best is from the Sorrento Bakery.
By steve180 - reader
Tuesday, 23rd of August @ 01:24 am
I haven't yet sampled these, but I do know of the supreme Vanilla Slice joy to be found at the Sorrento Bakery, as mentioned by the previous reader!
By eve.a - reader
Tuesday, 23rd of August @ 03:51 am
Heresy, absolute heresy.

There can be only One, and that One is The French Lettuce!
By RossChapman - senior reviewer
Tuesday, 23rd of August @ 05:37 am
Agree, the one from Refectory in Sydney Rd, Brunswick is heavenly, however, I havent tried the one at French Lettuce ... Will go there tomorrow!...well, then at least I can compare!
By glend16 - reader
Tuesday, 23rd of August @ 06:15 am
By far the best Vanilla Slice I know (mega VS fan here) is the Heather Dell Bakery (Yarraville) hand made at $2.60. Made with real cream custard and pastry yummmmm ... this link is a groovy review of their other well below average priced treats.
By maria - reader
Tuesday, 23rd of August @ 12:50 am
The one from green Refectory in Brunswick is pretty special! It has a passionfruit twist, so it's not for the purists, but YUM!
By jebesy - reader
Tuesday, 23rd of August @ 04:09 am
Rosedale Bakery also makes the best Vanilla slice. You are guaranteed that if you arent there early enough, they are all gone......VERY POPULAR!!
By Anonymous
Thursday, 25th of August @ 09:33 am
All gone? That sounds like a seriously good vanilla slice...
By Sue Williams - senior reviewer
Thursday, 25th of August @ 10:02 am
For me it would have to be the ones we used to buy on a Friday from Leos supermarket in Kew. They are delicious and we would keep them in the refridgerator only having to eat a half a one in a sitting as they are so wonderful.
By Jody Kimber - senior reviewer
Friday, 26th of August @ 01:54 am
Bayswater Bakery, Mountain Highway, Bayswater
By debra - reader
Saturday, 27th of August @ 11:09 am
'Goodness Gracious' on Riversdale road, Camberwell do the best vanilla slice. They're light and fluffy on the inside and crunchy on the outside, they also won a 'Vanilla Slice of the Year' award!
By Deveta Patel - senior reviewer
Wednesday, 9th of November @ 06:25 am
Lol! Nicely written, Sue! Bet your book is a laugh! Thanks for the tip. Other journeymen/women to the Wimmera region may know Waak's Bakery, central Horsham CBD & Hall's Gap Bakery (by the creek). Bragging superior custardy contributions, get in early, I say. Annie
By p.bro - reader
Thursday, 15th of November @ 10:54 pm
Best vanilla slice
Just Fine Foods in Sorrento
By Anonymous
Monday, 3rd of December @ 10:14 am
Thanks for the tip. I'll have to check out Goodness Gracious next time I'm in Camberwell.
By Sue Williams - senior reviewer
Thursday, 10th of November @ 06:00 am
2 hours north of melbourne a little cafe, the giddy goat. They are really really good!
By Anonymous
Friday, 6th of July @ 10:19 am
Rosa's Bakery, High St, Cranbourne.
-the delicious snot block kind with the fluffly custard and icing sugar on top! I always buy two.
By kafkapants - reader
Friday, 9th of November @ 01:27 am
Bayswater.Heavenly Pies.
By vicki - reader
Sunday, 25th of November @ 10:25 am
House of Bread and Pastries in Brighton
By Anonymous
Tuesday, 5th of March @ 09:45 pm
Vanilla slice from Tatura Hot Bread is really good! They deserve the trophy.
By kristine - reader
Thursday, 28th of December @ 06:54 pm

More Melbourne articles
Articles from other cities
Top Events
Popular Articles