Subscribe      List an Event or Business      Invite a Writer      Write for WN      Writers      Other Locations

Total Recall vs. Total Recall

Home > Everywhere > Cinema | Film Reviews | Movie Reviews
by Chrystal Byrne (subscribe)
Freelance writer living on Brisbane's north side. Studied creative industries - currently studying library and information services.
Published August 26th 2012
The new vs the old
Total Recall (2012), directed by Len Wiseman and starring Irishman Colin Farrell and brunette beauties Kate Beckinsale and Jessica Biel, is a remake of the 1990 Total Recall directed by Paul Verhoeven; starring buff-man Arnold Schwarzenegger and blonde siren Sharon Stone. Total Recall (both the 1990 and 2012 versions) were inspired and loosely based on the short story We Can Remember It for You Wholesale by Philip K. Dick.

Total Recall (1990) vs. Total Recall (2012)
Total Recall (1990) vs. Total Recall (2012)

The latest version of Total Recall follows much the same formula as its 90s predecessor. That is, strong 'hunky' male lead (I'm sorry, but I've never found Arnie to be good-looking at all) Schwarzenegger/Farrell, teamed with/against an attractive and desirable 'wife' Stone/Beckinsale, and a beautiful intelligent lover Rachel Ticotin/Biel. Beckinsale's character Lori does have a much larger role (and a lot more screen time) in the latest Total Recall than Stone's Lori had in 1990. Beckinsale herself is a spy in the latest adaptation and hunts Farrell and Biel with an almost life-driven intensity. In the original Total Recall, Stone seemed to be just a pretty thing to look at.

Total Recall (2012) also follows much of the same plot as Total Recall (1990) – and I must say it is an interesting premise, even the second time around. Douglas Quaid (Schwarzenegger/Farrell) dreams of an alternate life – so much so that he visits Rekall, a company that implants artificial memories, and chooses to be implanted with memories of life as a secret agent. In both films this goes terribly wrong – and is the catalyst for all that comes next.

In the 1990 version of Total Recall, where humans have not only conquered space travel but live on other planets as well – Schwarzenegger dreams of his implanted adventure taking place on the planet Mars. In the 2012 version, where Earth has been reduced to two territories in the aftermath of the bio-chemical warfare of the Third World War, Farrell just 'knows' he's meant for something else.

Total Recall (1990) vs. Total Recall (2012)
Schwarzenegger and Farrell

Setting is really the main difference between the 1990 and 2012 Total Recall films. Whilst both are set in the future, Schwarzenegger's film begins on Earth but is set on the planet Mars where political rebellion is rife. Farrell's Total Recall is set completely on Earth, but a very different Earth to what we know. Separated into two regions – the United Federation of Britain and the Colony – political rebellion has broken out in the working class' domain.

Something else I picked up on whilst watching the latest Total Recall was the total lack of gross, bloody and highly unnecessary violent scenes. Total Recall (1990) was full of them. Yes, the latest version has gun-fights and hand-to-hand combat, but none of the over-exaggerated blood spurts, loss of limbs or 'mutations' (excepting of course, the three-breasted woman, who does make a reappearance in Total Recall (2012)).

Total Recall (1990)
Schwarzenegger and Ticotin as Quaid and Melina

Total Recall (2012)
Farrell and Biel as Quaid and Melina

So here's my personal dot list of noted differences (you may class this as a 'spoiler alert') between Total Recall (1990) and Total Recall (2012):

Lori – plays a much larger role in the 2012 version and is actually pretty kick-ass

Setting – Mars vs. post-apocalyptic Earth

Fight scenes – 1990 version is more about bloody gun-fights whilst 2012 version is more physical fighting

Mutants – 1990 version contains mutants on Mars, 2012 contains lower socio-economic society on the Colony

Technology – Schwarzenegger's world dreamt up some pretty cool technology (enabling humans to live on Mars), but its nothing compared to the technological advancements seen in Farrell's world (hover cars, magnetic force weaponry, synthetic police, 'the fall' etc)

'The helper' – in the 1990 version 'a friend' of Quaid/Hauser's gives him the suitcase that puts him on the path to identity retrieval, but this 'friend' is actually sided with Cohaagen. In the 2012 version, a friend calls Quaid/Hauser and informs him that he is in danger. This friend, although working for Cohaagen, does actually sympathise with the Rebels and helps Quaid/Hauser escape from Cohaagen's grasp – losing his life in the process.

Well, there you have it, the differences between the two Total Recall films. There's not a great deal of them, but I think it's enough. Total Recall (2012) does follow the same principle ideas and plotlines as Total Recall (1990), but the amazing fight scenes, the stronger presence of Lori and the modernity of the film (and the absence of horrible gory/bloody scenes) reinvigorated the whole premise for me. I still like both films – there's great entertainment value in both.

Help us improve  Click here if you liked this article  14
Share: email  facebook  twitter
Why? Because you want to see the 2012 remake of the 1990 version of Total Recall
When: Now.
Where: In cinemas near you.
Cost: An adult ticket from Event Cinemas is usually $16.50
Your Comment
The original movie is far better, both my husband and myself, think the new one is no where near as good as the original. The original one had more in it as well.
by Tammy (score: 0|4) 2485 days ago
Not sure if i want to watch the new one as the original one is one of those classic movies that i think shouldn't be remade. Especially if the new version is worse than the original.. It just doesnt feel right
by anggi (score: 0|4) 2483 days ago
More Everywhere articles
Articles from other cities
by Nini on 21/08/2012
by Chrystal Byrne on 23/08/2012
by Jordan Hughes on 10/09/2012
by Chrystal Byrne on 23/08/2012
Popular Articles