The Place Beyond the Pines - Film Review

Post

Subscribe

Released in 2012, The Place Beyond the Pines, directed by Derek Cianfrance, is an ambitious and emotionally complex film that examines the intergenerational consequences of choices, the nature of legacy, and the cyclical nature of violence. Divided into three distinct acts, the movie weaves together the lives of a motorcycle stuntman turned bank robber, a morally conflicted cop, and their respective sons. Featuring a star-studded cast including Ryan Gosling, Bradley Cooper, Eva Mendes, and Dane DeHaan, the film transcends its crime drama trappings to explore profound themes of morality, fate, and fatherhood.

The narrative of The Place Beyond the Pines unfolds in three interconnected acts, each focusing on a different protagonist:

Luke Glanton (Ryan Gosling): A motorcycle stuntman discovers he has a son with his ex-lover, Romina (Eva Mendes). Determined to provide for his child, Luke turns to robbing banks, a decision that sets off a tragic chain of events.

Avery Cross (Bradley Cooper): A rookie cop who encounters Luke during a bank heist, Avery grapples with guilt and moral dilemmas in the aftermath. His ambition to rise in the police force collides with the corrupt system he becomes a part of.

Jason and AJ (Dane DeHaan and Emory Cohen): The teenage sons of Luke and Avery, respectively, whose lives intersect in unexpected and volatile ways.

This triptych structure allows the film to span generations, offering a sweeping yet intimate look at how the choices of fathers echo through the lives of their children.



Fatherhood is the central theme of The Place Beyond the Pines. Luke’s desperate attempt to provide for his son reflects his longing to be more than a fleeting presence in the boy’s life. Avery, on the other hand, struggles to balance his ambition with his role as a father, often prioritizing his career over his family.

The impact of these fathers’ decisions becomes evident in the third act, where Jason and AJ inherit the consequences of their fathers’ actions. The film suggests that the legacy of fathers—whether through love, neglect, or violence—inevitably shapes their children’s identities and choices.


Cianfrance refuses to draw clear lines between heroes and villains. Luke, despite his criminal actions, is portrayed as a loving father driven by desperation. Avery, though initially noble, succumbs to the corrupting influence of power and ambition.

This moral ambiguity extends to the systemic corruption depicted in the police force. Avery’s whistleblowing, though seemingly righteous, is driven as much by self-interest as by integrity. The film’s refusal to offer easy answers underscores the complexity of human behaviour and the far-reaching consequences of our actions.

The film explores how violence perpetuates itself across generations. Luke’s bank robberies lead to his death at Avery’s hands, an act that haunts both Avery and Luke’s son, Jason. Years later, Jason’s confrontation with AJ, Avery’s son, threatens to repeat the cycle of violence.

However, the film ends on a note of potential redemption, as Jason chooses to break free from the cycle by leaving his past behind. This decision suggests that while we are shaped by our parents’ choices, we are not doomed to repeat them.

Class divides loom large in The Place Beyond the Pines. Luke’s descent into crime stems from his inability to provide for his son through honest means, highlighting the systemic barriers faced by the working class. In contrast, Avery’s privileged background and position as a cop afford him opportunities to manipulate the system for his benefit.

These disparities are further reflected in Jason and AJ’s lives. Jason grows up in modest circumstances, while AJ enjoys the privileges of wealth and status. The tension between their backgrounds underscores the role of socioeconomic factors in shaping identity and opportunity.

Luke Glanton (Ryan Gosling): Gosling’s portrayal of Luke is both magnetic and heart-breaking. With his tattooed physique and reckless demeanour, Luke embodies the archetype of the tragic antihero. Gosling conveys Luke’s vulnerability and desperation with subtlety, making his criminal actions feel like the inevitable outcome of his circumstances.

Luke’s arc is the emotional anchor of the film, and his death at the end of the first act leaves a lasting impact on the story and the audience.

Avery Cross (Bradley Cooper): Bradley Cooper delivers a layered performance as Avery, a man torn between his ideals and his ambition. Initially presented as a foil to Luke, Avery’s moral struggles reveal him to be just as flawed and conflicted.

Cooper captures Avery’s evolution from an idealistic rookie to a cynical politician, showcasing the corrupting influence of power and guilt. His interactions with his estranged family add depth to his character, highlighting the personal cost of his ambition.

Romina (Eva Mendes): Eva Mendes shines as Romina, a woman caught between her past with Luke and her present with her new partner, Kofi. Mendes imbues Romina with quiet strength and vulnerability, making her a compelling presence despite her limited screen time.

Romina’s perspective provides a grounding counterpoint to the male-driven narratives, emphasizing the sacrifices and resilience of women in the face of their partners’ destructive choices.

Jason (Dane DeHaan) and AJ (Emory Cohen): Dane DeHaan and Emory Cohen deliver powerful performances as Jason and AJ, respectively. DeHaan captures Jason’s quiet intensity and yearning for identity, while Cohen portrays AJ’s brash, self-destructive arrogance with conviction.

Their volatile relationship mirrors the unresolved tensions between their fathers, serving as a microcosm of the film’s exploration of inherited conflict and the possibility of breaking free from it.

Derek Cianfrance’s direction is both ambitious and intimate, blending sweeping narrative scope with an intense focus on character. The film’s naturalistic style, characterized by long takes and handheld camera work, creates a sense of immediacy and emotional authenticity.

Cinematographer Sean Bobbitt captures the contrasting landscapes of Schenectady, New York, with stunning precision. The dense woods and desolate roads reflect the characters’ isolation and struggles, while the intimate close-ups emphasize their inner turmoil.

Mike Patton’s haunting score complements the film’s sombre tone, blending orchestral and experimental elements to evoke a sense of unease and inevitability. The use of recurring motifs mirrors the film’s themes of cyclical violence and legacy.

The soundtrack also features carefully chosen songs, such as Bon Iver’s The Wolves (Act I and II), which underscores the film’s emotional climaxes and reinforces its themes of loss and redemption.

While The Place Beyond the Pines received critical acclaim for its ambition and performances, some critics argued that its triptych structure led to uneven pacing. The transition between acts, particularly the shift from Luke’s story to Avery’s, was seen by some as jarring.

Despite these criticisms, the film was widely praised for its thematic depth and emotional resonance. It has since gained a reputation as a bold and thought-provoking exploration of morality and legacy.

The Place Beyond the Pines is a masterful blend of crime drama and family saga, offering a profound meditation on the choices that define us and the legacies we leave behind. Through its richly drawn characters, intricate narrative structure, and evocative visuals, the film explores the complexities of fatherhood, morality, and the struggle to break free from cycles of violence and regret.

While its ambitious scope may not resonate with all viewers, The Place Beyond the Pines remains a deeply affecting and thought-provoking work that lingers long after the credits roll. Its message—that we are shaped by our past but not bound by it—resonates universally, making it a modern cinematic classic.

%wneverywhere
#film_reviews
#movie_reviews
#date_night
#film_tv_reviews
#drama
#thriller