Nightmare Alley - Film Review

Post

Subscribe

Guillermo del Toro’s Nightmare Alley (2021) is a psychological thriller and neo-noir film based on William Lindsay Gresham’s 1946 novel of the same name. It serves as a remake of the 1947 film adaptation starring Tyrone Power but offers a darker, more visually stunning interpretation of the material. The film explores themes of deception, ambition, morality, and self-destruction, following a charismatic conman who manipulates his way to the top, only to face devastating consequences. Boasting a stellar cast, including Bradley Cooper, Cate Blanchett, Rooney Mara, Toni Collette, Willem Dafoe, and Richard Jenkins, Nightmare Alley is a haunting tale that merges film noir aesthetics with del Toro’s signature storytelling approach.

The film opens in the late 1930s, following Stanton "Stan" Carlisle (Bradley Cooper), a drifter who takes up work at a travelling carnival after burning down his childhood home. Under the guidance of carnival owner Clem Hoatley (Willem Dafoe), Stan learns about the world of sideshows, particularly the grim practice of "geeking"—a degrading act in which a desperate man is forced to bite the heads off live animals in exchange for alcohol and shelter.

Stan becomes intrigued by Zeena (Toni Collette) and Pete (David Strathairn), a married couple performing a mentalist act. Pete, a former star in the field, teaches Stan the secrets of cold reading and coded tricks used to convince audiences of supernatural abilities. However, Pete warns Stan against using the techniques for "spook shows," or conning people into believing they can communicate with the dead. Stan grows ambitious, forms a romantic bond with Molly (Rooney Mara), and eventually leaves the carnival to start a high-end mentalist act in the city.

In 1941, Stan and Molly build a successful career in Buffalo, New York, performing for the elite. He markets himself as a psychic with the ability to read minds and communicate with the deceased. His ambition leads him to cross paths with Dr. Lilith Ritter (Cate Blanchett), a cunning and intelligent psychologist who sees through his act but offers to help him exploit her wealthy patients.

One of these clients is Ezra Grindle (Richard Jenkins), a dangerous and powerful businessman haunted by the death of his lover. Stan attempts to con Grindle by fabricating a séance, but as the stakes rise, his deception spirals out of control. Meanwhile, his relationship with Molly deteriorates as she becomes increasingly disturbed by his greed and lack of ethics.

As Stan manipulates Grindle further, he underestimates Lilith’s true intentions. She ultimately betrays him, revealing that she has been recording their conversations and intends to frame him for fraud. Realizing he has been outplayed, Stan becomes desperate. His final confrontation with Grindle turns violent, forcing him to flee.

Broke, alone, and hunted, Stan finds himself back at a carnival, where he seeks work. In a grim twist of fate, the carnival owner offers him a job as a geek—an ironic and tragic conclusion to his arc. The film ends with Stan’s horrifying realization that he has become the very thing he once despised.



Stanton Carlisle (Bradley Cooper): Stan is a deeply flawed protagonist, embodying themes of unchecked ambition, moral corruption, and self-destruction. He starts as a quiet but observant drifter, learning and adapting to new opportunities. His intelligence and charm allow him to manipulate others, but his arrogance leads to his downfall.

Bradley Cooper delivers a nuanced performance, portraying Stan’s transformation from an ambitious conman to a broken shell of a man. His final scene, in which he laughs and weeps at the realization that he has become a geek, is one of the most harrowing moments in the film.

Dr. Lilith Ritter (Cate Blanchett): Lilith is a classic femme fatale, embodying intelligence, allure, and ruthless cunning. Unlike Stan, she does not let greed cloud her judgment. She is always in control, manipulating him just as he manipulates others.

Blanchett’s performance is chilling, blending seduction with menace. Her character represents a mirror image of Stan—just as deceitful but far more calculated.

Molly Cahill (Rooney Mara): Molly serves as the moral compass of the film. She genuinely loves Stan but cannot follow him down his path of deception. Unlike him, she values honesty and integrity, ultimately choosing to walk away when he pushes his schemes too far.

Rooney Mara brings a sense of innocence to the role, making Molly’s disillusionment all the more tragic. Her departure symbolizes the final fracture in Stan’s world.

Ezra Grindle (Richard Jenkins): Grindle is a powerful yet deeply disturbed man. He seeks redemption but is easily manipulated due to his guilt over a past lover’s death. However, he is also volatile, and his violent confrontation with Stan underscores the dangers of playing with people’s emotions.

Jenkins’ portrayal makes Grindle a terrifying figure—a man who, despite his remorse, is still capable of cruelty.

Clem Hoatley (Willem Dafoe): Clem is the carnival’s sinister ringmaster, introducing Stan to the darkest aspects of human exploitation. His description of how one turns a man into a geek foreshadows Stan’s fate, making him one of the film’s most important figures.

Dafoe’s performance is unsettling, capturing the mix of charm and malice that defines Clem’s character.

Both Stan and Lilith believe they can control others, yet both ultimately face moments where their schemes turn against them. Stan’s downfall shows that manipulation and ambition can only go so far before fate intervenes. Stan’s desire for wealth and status blinds him to the moral consequences of his actions. His unwillingness to stop pushing boundaries leads to his inevitable ruin.

The film is structured as a tragic cycle. Stan starts as a man escaping his past, only to end up exactly where he began—destitute and desperate. This mirrors noir’s fatalistic perspective that characters cannot escape their destinies. The concept of the "geek" represents ultimate degradation. Stan’s transformation into a geek symbolizes how he has lost everything, including his dignity.

Dan Laustsen’s cinematography employs deep shadows, chiaroscuro lighting, and rich colour palettes reminiscent of classic film noir. The carnival sequences contrast with the sleek, cold visuals of the city, emphasizing Stan’s transition from an earthy conman to a polished fraud.

The film’s production design is impeccable, with detailed 1940s sets that immerse the viewer in both the grimy world of carnivals and the opulent settings of the wealthy elite. Nathan Johnson’s score enhances the film’s eerie atmosphere, blending orchestral tension with melancholic themes. Sound design is particularly effective in creating suspense, especially during the séances and moments of psychological manipulation.

While Nightmare Alley received positive reviews, it was overshadowed by other films during its awards season run. Critics praised its performances, visuals, and faithful adaptation of the novel’s dark themes, but some audiences found its slow pacing and bleak narrative difficult to engage with. Despite this, the film has gained appreciation as a well-crafted noir drama that stays true to its genre’s themes of ambition and downfall.

Nightmare Alley (2021) is a masterful reimagining of classic noir, offering a haunting character study of a man consumed by his own greed. With stellar performances, stunning visuals, and a compelling narrative, the film stands as a testament to Guillermo del Toro’s storytelling prowess. It serves as both a cautionary tale and a dark meditation on fate, deception, and self-destruction.

%wneverywhere
#film_reviews
#movie_reviews
#film_tv_reviews
#thriller
#crime
#drama