Must Love Dogs - Film Review

Post

Subscribe

Must Love Dogs (2005), directed by Gary David Goldberg and based on Claire Cook's novel of the same name, is a romantic comedy that delves into the complexities of modern dating, familial bonds, and personal rediscovery. Starring Diane Lane and John Cusack, the film explores the challenges and humour of navigating romance in midlife. While light-hearted and formulaic in some respects, the movie offers a poignant look at love, loss, and starting over.

The story centres on Sarah Nolan (Diane Lane), a recently divorced preschool teacher in her late 30s who is struggling to move on from her failed marriage. Her large, meddling family, particularly her sister Carol (Elizabeth Perkins), is determined to help her find love again. Despite her reluctance, Sarah agrees to let her family set up an online dating profile for her, leading to a series of humorous and awkward encounters.

One of her dates is with Jake Anderson (John Cusack), a boat builder and hopeless romantic who is also recovering from a divorce. Jake’s passionate, idealistic view of love contrasts with Sarah’s cautious, jaded perspective. Despite their initial connection, misunderstandings and insecurities threaten to derail their budding relationship.

Complicating matters is Bob Connor (Dermot Mulroney), the charming father of one of Sarah’s students, who becomes a romantic distraction. As Sarah navigates the ups and downs of dating, she learns to embrace vulnerability, rediscover her sense of self, and open her heart to new possibilities.

At its core, Must Love Dogs is about the courage to start over after heartbreak. Both Sarah and Jake are grappling with the aftermath of failed marriages, and their journey underscores the idea that love can bloom even after significant setbacks. The film emphasises that second chances in love often require self-reflection, patience, and the willingness to take risks.

Sarah’s family plays a central role in her journey, providing both comic relief and heartfelt moments. Their well-meaning interference highlights the importance of familial support during times of personal crisis, even when their involvement feels overbearing.

The film humorously explores the pitfalls of online dating, blind dates, and the awkwardness of meeting potential partners later in life. It captures the frustrations and absurdities of trying to connect in an increasingly digital world, making it relatable for audiences navigating similar experiences.

Sarah’s journey is not just about finding love but also about rediscovering her own identity. Her divorce forces her to confront who she is outside of her marriage, and her romantic misadventures help her reclaim her confidence and sense of humour.



Sarah Nolan (Diane Lane): Diane Lane delivers a charming and relatable performance as Sarah, capturing her vulnerability, wit, and resilience. Sarah’s character arc is central to the film, as she evolves from a hesitant, heartbroken woman to someone who embraces the unpredictability of love. Lane’s portrayal strikes a balance between humour and poignancy, making Sarah a sympathetic and engaging protagonist.

Jake Anderson (John Cusack): John Cusack brings his trademark blend of earnestness and quirkiness to the role of Jake. A hopeless romantic who builds handcrafted boats, Jake is a refreshing departure from typical romantic comedy leads. His idealism and vulnerability make him both endearing and relatable, and his chemistry with Lane adds depth to their relationship.

Bob Connor (Dermot Mulroney): Bob serves as a foil to Jake, representing the kind of charming yet ultimately unreliable partner Sarah must learn to avoid. Dermot Mulroney’s suave performance captures Bob’s appeal while hinting at his lack of emotional depth. Bob’s role in the story underscores Sarah’s growth as she learns to prioritise genuine connection over superficial attraction.

Carol Nolan (Elizabeth Perkins): As Sarah’s sister, Carol is both her biggest cheerleader and a source of comedic tension. Elizabeth Perkins delivers a sharp, witty performance, providing much of the film’s humour. Carol’s well-meaning but intrusive efforts to help Sarah highlight the complexities of sibling relationships.

Bill Nolan (Christopher Plummer): Christopher Plummer shines as Sarah’s widowed father, Bill, who is navigating his own romantic adventures. Bill’s subplot, involving his relationships with multiple women, mirrors Sarah’s journey and adds a layer of depth to the film’s exploration of love at different life stages.

Gary David Goldberg, known for his work in television (Family Ties), brings a light, sitcom-like touch to the film. While the direction occasionally lacks subtlety, Goldberg effectively balances humour and sentimentality, creating a warm and engaging tone. The cinematography by John Bailey captures the film’s romantic and comedic essence. The use of soft lighting and picturesque settings, such as parks, cosy homes, and waterfronts, enhances the film’s warm, inviting atmosphere.

Craig Armstrong’s score complements the film’s tone, blending light-hearted and emotional melodies. The soundtrack, featuring songs by artists like Sheryl Crow and Natalie Cole, adds to the film’s romantic and contemporary feel. The editing by Roger Bondelli maintains a steady pace, ensuring that the film’s humour and emotional beats land effectively. The transitions between Sarah’s romantic misadventures and her family interactions are seamless, contributing to the film’s cohesive narrative.

The film’s exploration of love, family, and self-discovery resonates with audiences, particularly those navigating midlife transitions. Diane Lane and John Cusack deliver engaging performances, supported by a talented ensemble cast. The film strikes a balance between comedic moments and heartfelt scenes, creating an enjoyable viewing experience. The humorous depiction of online dating and blind dates adds a relatable, contemporary dimension to the story.

The film adheres to romantic comedy conventions, making the storyline somewhat predictable. While Bill’s romantic escapades and Sarah’s family dynamics add depth, some subplots feel underexplored. The film doesn’t break new ground in the genre, relying on familiar tropes and formulas.

Sarah and Jake’s initial meeting is a standout scene, filled with humour and awkwardness. Their contrasting personalities—Sarah’s guarded scepticism and Jake’s romantic idealism—are on full display, setting the stage for their evolving relationship.

Sarah’s family’s decision to create her online dating profile leads to a series of comedic and heartfelt moments. This scene highlights the film’s exploration of familial support and interference, as well as Sarah’s reluctance to embrace change.

The film’s climax, in which Jake dramatically declares his feelings for Sarah, is a classic romantic comedy moment. While predictable, it is executed with sincerity and charm, providing a satisfying resolution to their love story.

Must Love Dogs offers a light-hearted yet insightful commentary on the challenges of modern romance. The film highlights the evolving landscape of dating, particularly for those re-entering the scene after divorce or loss. It also critiques societal pressures on women to find love, emphasising the importance of self-discovery and personal fulfilment. The film’s portrayal of family dynamics reflects the complexities of contemporary relationships, showcasing both the support and tension that can arise within close-knit families.

Must Love Dogs received mixed reviews from critics. While praised for its charming performances and relatable themes, the film was criticised for its formulaic plot and lack of originality. Some reviewers felt that it relied too heavily on romantic comedy clichés, limiting its emotional impact. The film resonated with audiences who appreciated its humour, warmth, and exploration of midlife romance. Its relatable characters and themes made it a popular choice for fans of the genre.

While not a ground-breaking entry in the romantic comedy genre, Must Love Dogs remains a beloved film for its heartfelt exploration of love and second chances. It continues to resonate with viewers seeking light-hearted, feel-good entertainment.

Must Love Dogs is a charming and relatable romantic comedy that explores the challenges and joys of finding love later in life. While its predictable plot and reliance on genre tropes may limit its appeal for some, the film’s strong performances, humour, and heartfelt themes make it a worthwhile watch. Diane Lane and John Cusack’s chemistry anchors the narrative, creating a love story that is both entertaining and emotionally resonant. Ultimately, Must Love Dogs is a testament to the resilience of the human heart and the enduring possibility of love, no matter one’s age or circumstances.

%wneverywhere
#film_reviews
#movie_reviews
#film_tv_reviews
#comedy
#romance