Subscribe      List an Event or Business      Invite a Writer      Write for WN      Writers      Other Locations
list an event      1 million Australian readers every month      facebook

Where's the Best Vanilla Slice in Sydney?

Home > Sydney > Shopping | Food and Wine | Cafes | Questions
Your Answer
share your local knowledge
Writer's Answer:
by Sue Williams (subscribe)
Writer, bushwalker, dessert enthusiast. Author of the Rusty Bore Mysteries. More info here:
Published October 20th 2011
One perfect vanilla slice moments before... it disappeared
One perfect vanilla slice moments before... it disappeared

The search for the best vanilla slice is one that can last a lifetime. This is a custardy crusade worthy of a tick box under "Religion" on the Census.

Some people perform good deeds, some spend years learning to meditate and others head to the Kingdom of Bhutan. But to those in pursuit of true happiness, I say: get thee to the shrine of the perfect vanilla slice.

So whereabouts in Sydney should the custard pilgrim head? We're looking here for the very best vanilla slices Sydney has to offer. Nothing limp or rubbery, lacking in true custard flavour or in pastry that's damp or just downright nasty.

What we're seeking is a smooth custardy centre nestled in crisp, fresh pasty - the kind of vanilla slice that's messily irresistible, leaving morsels of creamy custard and crumbs of crunchy pastry speckled on your face. The kind that may even cause the devoted pilgrim to produce small, embarrassing snuffles and/or moans as they eat.

Note: regardless of your vanilla slice deportment, you can take comfort that this is a slice entrenched in culture. It's said (at least according to the gospels of Wikipedia) that the custardy forebear of the humble snot block is none other than the mille-feuille, originating in France.

Mille feuille by Zantastik, Wikipedia
Mille feuille by Zantastik, Wikipedia

Anyway. Lead us now to the absolute best vanilla slices Sydney has to offer. Please, before the tummy rumbles get any worse.

Some suggestions to get us started. There's the highly rated specimen at La Renaissance Café Pâtisserie.

And the Boronia Bakehouse, at 95a Pittwater Road, Boronia Park has been known to purvey a very decent double-decker vanilla slice. (Note however, that a double-decker snot block is not one to eat on a first date. Not unless you have snake-like jaws that know how to unhinge - double-deckers can be tricky to get into with dignity intact).

Another fine vanilla slice establishment is La Petite Lorraine , who take matters of custard very seriously.

And there are excellent reports from the Gelato Bar Bakery.

Now it's over to you. If you have a preferred shrine to the vanilla slice in Sydney or indeed anywhere in NSW, please let us know by leaving a comment below.
Help us improve  Click here if you liked this article  50
Share: email  facebook  twitter
Sugarloaf at Kogarah serve French and Dutch Vanilla Slices which are both yummy
by rcurr (score: 1|18) 2677 days ago
Wow - Dutch vanilla slices sound interesting.
by Sue Williams (score: 2|838) 2670 days ago
The best vanilla slice in Sydney can be found at the "Muffin Master" shop located at shop 18 Princes Hwy Sylvania ( at the end of Tom Ugly's Bridge going south of Sydney)
by lynnd (score: 1|11) 2666 days ago
Muffin Master now renamed, contact number 95447693 located just immediately South after crossing Tom Ugly Bridge. That's my favourite vanilla slice haunt. Nothing extravagant just beautiful custard that's not too sweet and crispy fresh pastry.
by Vick1 (score: 0|4) 1126 days ago
CAKE BIZ at Narellan is amazing, crisp pastry and creamy custard. Delish!
by trace119 (score: 1|17) 1660 days ago
As a Victorian - we have a proud history in vanilla slices with the ouyen annual v slice contest - sydney is a desert for a decent vanilla slice. :-(. It is next to impossible to find one without either passion fruit icing or dusted with icing sugar - neither of which constitute a proper vanilla slice. Best vanilla slice ever comes from the tiny mallee town of birchip - they won the ouyen contest last year - the custard is amazing. Conways in Horsham do a good one too. I wait til I go back to Victoria to get a decent vanilla slice. Have not been able to find something acceptable on the north shore. If anyone knows of one I will be sooo grateful!!!
by richa (score: 0|2) 2087 days ago
Pattisons Bakery have a very nice custard tart which is similar in texture to vanilla slice - very tasty!!
by lg (score: 1|13) 2407 days ago
Davids Cakes - North Carlingford
by strex (score: 0|2) 2449 days ago
Gelato Bar Bondi beach and bonid junction -- on the day they are made if poss -- hard to beat........
by pamel30 (score: 0|2) 2657 days ago
Pattison's at ST IVES (Sydney's North Shore).

Looking for a Blue Mountains/ Lithgow/Mudgee outlet please.
by Gloria (score: 2|170) 237 days ago

More Sydney articles
Articles from other cities
Foodi Photoh Classie
Top Events
Popular Articles