Subscribe      List an Event or Business      Invite a Writer      Write for WN      Writers      Other Locations

Best Cupcakes in New York

Home > New York > Food and Wine | Tours | Lists
by Joann Jovinelly (subscribe)
I'm a freelance writer/photographer living in the East Village neighborhood of New York City.
Published March 2nd 2011
New Yorkers have long been fascinated by portable confections, but none have seduced them as well as the cupcake, the much lauded personalized baked good that keeps recreating itself. New York has cupcakes from bakeries on wheels, mini cupcakes, massive cupcakes, and even vegan varieties. In fact, you'd be hard-pressed not to find a favorite cupcake in this town (though the doughnut is edging in ever-so-slightly as the next gourmet dessert tsunami). Below are a select group of five New York favorites; feel free to compare them one by one in a delicious cupcake eating tour.

Buttercup Bake Shop
973 Second Avenue (b'w 51st and 52nd Streets) &
141 W. 72nd St. (b'w Amsterdam and Columbus)
This jewel of an uptown bakery has locations on the east and west sides of Manhattan, which makes the task of bringing home something sweet that much easier. Look for old-fashioned homemade favorites like banana pudding, bar cookies, and pies among the wide variety of cupcakes; our favorite is the "Devil Dog". Buttercup Bake Shop also offers delivery.

Sugar Sweet Sunshine
126 Rivington Street
Sugar Sweet Sunshine, a small Lower East Side Bakery, has been happily serving New Yorkers' since 2003 with its perfectly rich, perfectly fresh cupcakes laden with a sugary sweet and almond- or vanilla-infused frosting. Cosmic colors and unusual flavors like pistachio make these cupcakes a surefire hit at any party or get-together. Everything a cupcake should be! They even offer same-day delivery in Manhattan—somebody hide the bathroom scale.

Cupcake Café
545 Ninth Avenue &
18 W. 18th Street
The beautiful creations seen here were created by the Cupcake Café, a longtime city favorite, now with two locations. Delicate floral details like these are hand piped all year long and make great gifts for special occasions such as birthdays. With two sizes available, they're as easy to share as they are to gobble on your own. Favors are fairly basic: a densely packed vanilla or chocolate cake with a not-too-sweet chocolate, vanilla, or mocha butter cream frosting.

Billy's Bakery
184 Ninth Avenue (b'w 21st and 22nd Streets) &
268 Elizabeth Street (b'w Prince and Houston Streets) &
75 Franklin Street (b'w B'way and Elizabeth Streets)
With an old-fashioned spin on new favorites like banana, coconut, and red velvet, Billy's Bakery is one step ahead of the competition. These cupcakes are heavenly delicious with ample amounts of butter cream to soothe the mightiest cravings. A rich, moist homemade cake, mellow in flavor, but strong enough to hold its own in a sea of cupcakery goodness. Now with three locations!

248 Broome Street (b'w Orchard & Ludlow Streets)
Free of flour, eggs, and dairy, this vegan treat from BabyCakes will be an absolute sensation with fussy mothers, animal-loving activists, and all your allergic-ailing friends. It might look pristine from the outset, but its taste is fabulously decadent. BabyCakes cupcakes and doughnuts (equally healthy) have wowed the New York critics with their mighty rich flavors, despite their lack of refined sugar. Plus, you might run into Madonna who is a big BabyCakes fan.

Photo credits: Buttercup Bake Shop by M Kasahara; Sugar Sweet Sunshine, Cupcafe Café by Reboppy; Billy's Bakery by Minnibeach; Babycakes by Cafemama/FlickrCC

Help us improve  Click here if you liked this article  47
Share: email  facebook  twitter
Why? To savor a unique taste in three bites.
When: Varies
Where: Varies
Cost: $2.75 and up
Great post, Joann. Sometimes, nothing hits the spot more than a yummy cupcake. We love cupcakes in my family. My girls love to bake them. But, we also love exploring our neighborhood and are always looking for great cupcake venues. We've been to Billy's Bakery and Cupcake Cafe, and agree that both places serve delish cupcakes. You've given us a great list to try out. Another wonderful place is Baked by Melissa where their mini cupcakes are big treats.
By Cristina Dimen - senior reviewer
Friday, 28th of October @ 05:58 pm
Sprinkles (uptown by Bloomingdale's) is also excellent. Good value, perfectly fresh, and easily boxed for gifting. I highly recommend.
By Joann Jovinelly - senior writer
Saturday, 29th of October @ 01:59 pm
Mmmmm, something tells me all my good work eating well of late will be undone when I arrive in NYC and start sampling these delicacies...
By Kathleen - senior reviewer
Monday, 19th of November @ 06:25 am
More New York articles
Articles from other cities
Popular Articles